University Press

Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

Jupiter campus senators challenged the University Wide Senate and its President Kyle MacDonald, who voted to pass the budget.

Photo courtesy of Student Government

Photo courtesy of Student Government

Benjamin Paley, Alexander Rodriguez

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Editor’s note | Feb. 14, 2018: A previous version of this story contained the headline: “Jupiter senators allege 2018-19 budget is ‘unconstitutional’” It has been updated to reflect the Student Government Court’s ruling.

The Student Government Court justices heard from three Jupiter campus senators challenging the University-Wide Budget and Appropriations Committee’s proposed budget Monday evening.

Senators Shannon Bieniek, Nicholas Tyndall, and Cody Steed claim UBAC budgeted for a non-existent Student Government entity, which they said violates SG statutes.

UBAC’s 2018-19 proposed budget would turn the Boca campus Program Board into a university-wide board and ultimately phase out the Davie and Jupiter campus’ board. The SG student-run program is responsible for organizing events on campus.  

“These statutes however, do not give the Senate or the UBAC any authority to budget for non-existent SG entities,” the senators wrote in their petition. “For these reasons, we ask that SGSSSB 1805 [UBAC’s budget] be declared unconstitutional.”

The petition challenges student body Vice President Kyle MacDonald and the University Wide Senate, which voted Jan. 25 to approve the budget. As vice president, MacDonald is the president of the Senate. 

MacDonald maintains that UBAC isn’t creating a new SG program, it’s modifying Program Board’s existing “funding structure.” 

“The bill in question does not violate any University policy or State policies,” MacDonald wrote in his response to the petition. “The petitioners voted no on the legislation and may not be happy with the passing of the legislation, however it does not mean that statutes are being violated.”

The Student Court justices asked and answered four questions before voting on the petition.

  1. Is the university-wide Program Board a new entity or just a structural adjustment?
    • A new entity
  2. Does UBAC have the authority to modify a SG program?
    • No
  3. Does UBAC have the ability to create a new SG entity?
    • No
  4. Is the 2018-19 budget unconstitutional?
    • Yes

After the justices stated their positions, the court voted 4-0 in favor of the Jupiter senators’ petition.

UBAC’s budget will now head back to the SG Senate for rewrite and reconsideration.

Benjamin Paley is the distribution manager of the University Press. For information regarding this or other stories, email [email protected].

Alexander Rodriguez is the news editor of the University Press. For information regarding this or other stories, email [email protected] or tweet @AARodriguezz93.

About the Writer
Benjamin Paley, Distribution Manager

Benjamin is a graduate student studying public administration, and has previously been a contributing writer. He hopes to work on Capitol Hill one day. During his off time, Benjamin enjoys reading a good book or watching British comedies.

1 Comment

One Response to “Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’”

  1. commenter on February 8th, 2018 5:51 pm

    please revise the headline. is not “alleged” if they voted in favor of the jupiter campus reps

Do you have something to say? Submit your comments below

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU researchers study sexual blackmail in teens

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU Boca governor discusses recent campus, Student Government accomplishments

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU to host eighth annual Drag Show this month

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU High School, A.D. Henderson receive educational award

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU researcher looks to reduce coastal erosion

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU Victim Services is missing its spokesperson for trauma survivors

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    About 40 candidates running for House of Representatives disqualified

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    2017 rapes on Boca campus more than double previous year

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    FAU places in top 30 of almost 300 universities for racial diversity

  • Student Government: 2018-19 budget deemed ‘unconstitutional’

    News

    Student body president outlines future Student Government initiatives