University Press

Filed under News, Top Stories

Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

Itamar Marcus spoke to an attentive crowd in the Grand Palm Room Monday night, drawing some applause and driving others to walk out in silent protest.

Itamar+Marcus+on+the+podium+talking+about+the+PMW+%28Palestinian+Media+Watch%29.%0A%5B+Mohammed+F+Emran+%7C+Web+Editor+%5D
Itamar Marcus on the podium talking about the PMW (Palestinian Media Watch).
[ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Itamar Marcus on the podium talking about the PMW (Palestinian Media Watch). [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Itamar Marcus on the podium talking about the PMW (Palestinian Media Watch). [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Itamar Marcus sat down with the University Press for an interview.  [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Itamar Marcus sat down with the University Press for an interview.
[ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Monday night in the Grand Palm room, Itamar Marcus — founder of Palestinian Media Watch, an Israel-based nongovernmental organization — discussed his views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and how Israel is portrayed in the Palestinian media.

The lecture was sponsored by StandWithUs , a pro-Israel advocacy group, and student organizations such as Owls for Israel and Alpha Epsilon Pi, a Jewish fraternity. The event did not appear in the FAU Master Calendar, regardless, attendance was high.

“We have over 200 seats and most of them are filled,” said Melody DeSanto, a StandWithUs Emerson fellow.

The Grand Palm room was filled with a row of chairs facing the podium and near the back, complementary coffee was available with an israeli flag on display behind the dispensers, tables were decorated with blue napkins donning the Star of David and Israeli candy.

Many of the older folks showed up for Itamar Marcus lecture.  [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Many of the older folks showed up for Itamar Marcus lecture.
[ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

The audience, mostly made up of middle-aged and senior citizens, made its way across the student union, with staff members directing them to the Grand Palm Room.

Non-students sat in the first eight rows, with the exception of an estimated 12 members of Students for Justice in Palestine and Dream Defenders, student-run social justice groups, sitting in the third and fourth rows. Members of Alpha Epsilon Pi and Owls for Israel occupied the last rows.

“I wouldn’t go somewhere where I didn’t like the speaker, unless it was Obama,” said an audience member while mingling with the crowd, but not all shared that viewpoint.

“You can’t promote hatred,” said Dolores Plaxen, a non-student attending the event. “if ever you see anyone whether it’s anti-semitism, whether it’s anti-Arab, whether it’s anti-Hispanic, you can’t encourage that.” Plaxen mentioned the Israel Tennis Center and how Israel promotes unity through sports.

In the beginning of the event, lights dimmed and  a video started to play from the host organization of the event.  [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

In the beginning of the event, lights dimmed and a video started to play from the host organization of the event. [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

At around 7:40, the lights dimmed and a video played, stating the objectives of StandWithUs, which include “informing the public about Israel and combating the extremism and anti-Semitism that often distorts the issues.”

A member of SJP placed her hands over her ears as the narrator began discussing Palestine and the views of StandWithUs on Palestinian education. After the video, DeSanto introduced keynote speaker Marcus, who was greeted with applause.

Marcus began his lecture with a history of how Palestinian Media Watch was founded. The lecture touched on a myriad of subjects regarding Israeli-Palestinian relationships. Marcus discussed how suicide bombers tend to be glorified in Palestinian culture and how children’s shows encourage anti-semitism.

Members from Students for Justice in Palestine and Dream Defenders quietly stood up and walked out of the lecture.  [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Members from Students for Justice in Palestine and Dream Defenders quietly stood up and walked out of the lecture. [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

He also touched on the problems of extremism and how both sides of the conflict could benefit if they engaged in mutual discourse. Marcus showed a powerpoint of what he said was “Palestinian propaganda” depicting a caricature of an Israeli soldier with his pants down threatening to rape a palestinian prisoner.

At this moment, members of SJP and Dream Defenders, some 20 total students, quietly stood up and walked out of the lecture, senior citizens and non-students in attendance began clapping.

Audience member John Mordecai yelled “Good riddance,” as the group left the Grand Palm room.

Mordecai told the UP he was glad they left. “I felt maybe the speaker would feel slightly intimidated,” adding that SJP members came off as intimidating.

The audience was allowed to answer questions after the lecture.  [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

The audience was allowed to ask questions after the lecture. [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

“At that moment it was absolutely barbaric, it showed this political cartoon totally out of context, totally depicting Palestinians as barbarians,” said SJP’s vice president Jihad Sheikha on his rationale for walking out.

Sweets and fruits were served at the speech event. [ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Sweets and fruits were served at the speech event.
[ Mohammed F Emran | Web Editor ]

Marcus continued the lecture by discussing Palestinian media and his work on school textbooks. When asked about the walkout, Marcus said “I was a little disappointed that the Muslim group left. I’d love to encounter with them and hope that they understand that this is actually peace promotion.”

“It was well played, it definitely got their message out there, Marcus has his own perspective and he’s entitled to it and they have their own perspective and they’re entitled to it,” said Nadav Alkoby, a political science major and member of Alpha Epsilon Pi.

3 Comments

3 Responses to “Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest”

  1. momisteries on November 14th, 2014 3:35 pm

    This guy is a joke. That he labeled a diverse group of students consisting of Muslim, Jewish, Christian, and atheist a “Muslim group” is indicative of his inbred bigotry and lack of legitimacy as an intellectual. It’s a shame that FAU allows racists, terrorists, bigots, and supporters of terrorism to speak on campus. It’s an even bigger shame that the community not only condones this, they celebrate it.

  2. Rayna Rose Exelbierd on November 17th, 2014 3:23 pm

    Perhaps had the students stayed, and challenged the speaker, then the speaker would know they were not all Muslim. It’s hilarious, that you as a member of SJP are complaining about the speaker- when your group has hosted speakers who deny the Holocaust, promote incitement such as the woman from the electronic intifada, and promote intimidating behavior on campus. The community celebrates diversity, and very few people clapped when you all left. Why show up to an event, if you aren’t going to stay? Owls for Israel may not agree with all the information in your events, but we have never walked out or had charges brought on us for disrupting your events.

  3. Melody on November 17th, 2014 4:26 pm

    It is unfortunate that the group of students walked out in the beginning of Itamar’s presentation. Itamar makes it clear that Peace is impossible without recognition of the alarming amount of incitement within the
    Palestinian Authority. The specific propaganda example that is mentioned in this article is a gruesome cartoon (view the image here: http://palwatch.org/main.aspx?fi=771&doc_id=12964) that was used by the Palestinian Authority to promote violence and praise terrorism. I am saddened that a student from SJP considered this part of the presentation a way of “totally depicting Palestinians as barbarians,” when in reality, this was Itamar’s way placing blame on the Palestinian Authority, not the Palestinian people. In America, when a government official makes a decision that is frowned upon, the response by the international community is NOT to blame all Americans for it, but rather blame the government itself. Why shouldn’t we do the same for the Palestinian Authority? At the end of the day, there is increasing evidence that the Palestinian Authority promotes incitement in ways such as using propaganda, naming sporting events after terrorists (as if it is a heroic act), and controlling text books. What Hillel, OwlsForIsrael, Chabbad, Alpha Epsilon Pi, and StandWithUs want more than anything is for things that block our path to Peace to come to come to an end.

Do you have something to say? Submit your comments below

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    FAU tackles opioid addiction epidemic with research group

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    FAU’s new initiative gives students cheaper Uber rides

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    We the Kings, Travis Porter set to headline fall bonfire concert

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    FAU police prepare for possible active shooter with Boca campus drill

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    Housing is spending $5.7 million on new air conditioning

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    A rundown of FAU’s summer hours

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    US Navy grants FAU $1.25 million to research driverless ships

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    Student Government discusses possible student Uber discounts, increased school security

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    College of Business receives $1.25 million donation for women’s leadership program

  • Media analyst Itamar Marcus discusses Israeli-Palestinian relations and responds to a walk-out protest

    News

    FAU poll: Floridians support Trump more than ever